1911 recommendations?

Gun, shooting and equipment discussions unrelated to CHL issues

Moderator: carlson1


Topic author
NcongruNt
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 7
Posts: 2416
Joined: Sun Feb 25, 2007 12:44 am
Location: Austin, Texas

1911 recommendations?

#1

Post by NcongruNt »

So I'm slowly mulling over the idea of getting a 1911 in the semi-near future - not for another 3 months or so, at least.

The recent activity in Tacomaoffroader's post regarding his 24/7 got me looking at the Taurus site. Then I remembered what those guns look like and couldn't bring myself to look at them and their weird oblong handles and plastic frames. :ack: So, I headed over to the 1911 section of the Taurus site instead. Oh the beautiful lines and styling of the 1911! No insult intended to anyone who carries a plastic gun, I just can't bring myself to like them personally.

So anyhow, I'll probably be in the market for a 1911 in a few months. I'm not looking for anything fancy or shiny or super-tuned or anything like that. Matte black or blued finish is what I want. A dark gun is much easier for me to conceal, as most of my clothes are dark, and black blends in better. I'd specifically like a 5" model. I don't want to spend a ton of money on it, I just want something basic and functional.

So... I have been looking around at 1911's, and specifically have been looking at both the STI Spartan and the Taurus PT 1911. I've also found that the basic Springfield GI and Mil-Spec models fall into the same price range. The Kimber Customs are a little more pricey, but it seems they all come with shiny stainless hammers, a feature I do not want for the sake of concealed carry.

Anyone have any advice or testimony regarding the reliability of these or any other 1911 pistols that can be had for a decent price?

Thanks in advance.
User avatar

G.A. Heath
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 1
Posts: 2983
Joined: Sat Mar 31, 2007 9:39 pm
Location: Western Texas

#2

Post by G.A. Heath »

I own a Taurus PT1911, its a nice gun that gives you a lot of features for the money. There are two things you should be aware of regarding the PT1911. The first issue is the finish, its not as good as it should be. The finish has a one year warranty while the rest of the gun has a lifetime warranty. The second issue is the dovetails for the sights are unique to the gun. While the gun has Heinie Straight-8 sights they utilize a Taurus only dovetail.

As an alternative to the Taurus you might consider a Rock Island Armory 1911, tactical. You can find them for sale on gunbroker by a guy called Bellshireguns for $425 (Buy now) and he will pay the shipping to your FFL if you use the "Buy Now" function. The Rock Island will have a life time warranty also.

Houston1944
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 1
Posts: 362
Joined: Thu Mar 30, 2006 1:37 pm
Location: Houston, TX

#3

Post by Houston1944 »

I think the best value for the money currently is the S&W 1911. I have two and they have been flawless. Another good option is the SA mil-spec (I am not a big fan of the "Loaded" series). The mil-spec is a good reliable firearm but the sights are not the best for conceal carry.

HankB
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 1
Posts: 1394
Joined: Mon Aug 08, 2005 2:03 pm
Location: Central TX, just west of Austin

#4

Post by HankB »

I like Les Baer pistols, but they may cost a bit more than what you're looking for.

I've heard nothing but good things about the current SW1911s . . . they seem to work well, though many people dislike the "don't be stupid" warning on the side. (Heard S&W was thinking about removing it, but that could be just wishful thinking . . .)

ALL other manufacturers of lower-priced 1911s seem to be putting out a noticeable percentage of lemons . . . and I, for one, don't like the idea of spending anywhere from hundreds to near $1000 for a new gun that I assume will have to be fixed . . .
Original CHL: 2000: 56 day turnaround
1st renewal, 2004: 34 days
2nd renewal, 2008: 81 days
3rd renewal, 2013: 12 days

TX Rancher
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 2
Posts: 518
Joined: Sun Oct 15, 2006 8:19 am
Location: Fayette Co

#5

Post by TX Rancher »

Houston1944 wrote:I think the best value for the money currently is the S&W 1911. I have two and they have been flawless. Another good option is the SA mil-spec (I am not a big fan of the "Loaded" series). The mil-spec is a good reliable firearm but the sights are not the best for conceal carry.
:iagree: Both are good options...

If this is going to be your carry weapon, and you're willing to bet your life on it, should cost be the deciding point? Seems reliability should be at the top of the list... looks, cost, finish, etc would all take second seat. Just something to think about ;-)
User avatar

stevie_d_64
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 2
Posts: 7590
Joined: Fri Mar 04, 2005 11:17 pm
Location: 77504

#6

Post by stevie_d_64 »

Looks like your list is short...You should be able to decide fairly easy, and be happy with what you choose...

There are a few folks going with the Taurus (I happen to like them)...That Smith is not something I would turn away from either...

Ain't shopping fun!

I guess we all love spending others money! :lol:
"Perseverance and Preparedness triumph over Procrastination and Paranoia every time.” -- Steve
NRA - Life Member
"Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?"
Μολών λαβέ!

Topic author
NcongruNt
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 7
Posts: 2416
Joined: Sun Feb 25, 2007 12:44 am
Location: Austin, Texas

#7

Post by NcongruNt »

TX Rancher wrote:
Houston1944 wrote:I think the best value for the money currently is the S&W 1911. I have two and they have been flawless. Another good option is the SA mil-spec (I am not a big fan of the "Loaded" series). The mil-spec is a good reliable firearm but the sights are not the best for conceal carry.
:iagree: Both are good options...

If this is going to be your carry weapon, and you're willing to bet your life on it, should cost be the deciding point? Seems reliability should be at the top of the list... looks, cost, finish, etc would all take second seat. Just something to think about ;-)
While your assessment is generally true, higher cost != higher reliability. In some cases it does, in others not so much. "Performance" and customization play a huge factor here, and I do not find it an unreasonable expectation to expect a $700 pistol with no special features or performance modifications to be reliable for carry duty.

I paid far less for my Hi-power, which has proven itself to me to be flawless in its reliability. It's never had a jam or failure in any way in the ~400 rounds I've put through it thus far. I trust it, and it is my daily carry. It also cost me $300 NIB. While it is a good deal even for an Argentine model, they still only generally go for around $400.

In another example, Glocks are known for being reliable guns. They are a favored gun of law enforcement agencies and officers who trust their lives to them every day. Pretty much any of their models can be had for less than $600, plain and stock.

While the SA mil-spec falls in the ~$700 range, the S&W is far too expensive to be reasonable for my needs. The line has to be drawn somewhere, and I think $700 is a reasonable one.

Topic author
NcongruNt
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 7
Posts: 2416
Joined: Sun Feb 25, 2007 12:44 am
Location: Austin, Texas

#8

Post by NcongruNt »

stevie_d_64 wrote:Looks like your list is short...You should be able to decide fairly easy, and be happy with what you choose...

There are a few folks going with the Taurus (I happen to like them)...That Smith is not something I would turn away from either...

Ain't shopping fun!

I guess we all love spending others money! :lol:
It's not that my list is short, it's more that my requirements are simple. Rereading what you wrote, maybe that's what you mean. ;-)

Black/blued, reliable, <=$700, nothing shiny.

I also don't know a whole lot about the world of 1911s, which is why I asked if anyone else had any in mind that would fit my requirements. I'm taking a look at the Rock Island guns suggested by G.A. Heath now.
User avatar

stevie_d_64
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 2
Posts: 7590
Joined: Fri Mar 04, 2005 11:17 pm
Location: 77504

#9

Post by stevie_d_64 »

Yep, thats what I meant...

Nothing flashy, fancy...Just so that it goes bang when I need it to...

If its ugly, and goes bang, even better...

Didn't realize you were looking at the Rock Island stuff as well...

I'm jealous...Yer having to much fun with this! ;-)
"Perseverance and Preparedness triumph over Procrastination and Paranoia every time.” -- Steve
NRA - Life Member
"Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?"
Μολών λαβέ!

Topic author
NcongruNt
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 7
Posts: 2416
Joined: Sun Feb 25, 2007 12:44 am
Location: Austin, Texas

#10

Post by NcongruNt »

stevie_d_64 wrote:Yep, thats what I meant...

Nothing flashy, fancy...Just so that it goes bang when I need it to...

If its ugly, and goes bang, even better...

Didn't realize you were looking at the Rock Island stuff as well...

I'm jealous...Yer having to much fun with this! ;-)
If only those Rock Island guns came with black grips instead! I guess I'd have to buy some replacement grips for it if I got one. Anyone have any experience with these?

That same seller also has a SA G.I. Champion hi-cap for $500 with shipping. Not too shabby.

DSARGE
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 1
Posts: 219
Joined: Wed Jan 17, 2007 6:20 pm
Location: San Antonio, TX, USA

#11

Post by DSARGE »

I got a Springfield GI .45 and absolutely love it. I have put several hundred rounds through it, and carry it almost exclusively. It pretty doggone accurate. I use a Galco IWB, and can easily conceal in shorts and T-shirt. Good luck.
I found the Lord again--although he never lost me!

Rex B
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 3
Posts: 3615
Joined: Thu Jul 06, 2006 3:30 pm
Location: DFW

RIA 1911s

#12

Post by Rex B »

Check with Sarco. They have several variations including the Tactical for under $400. Grips are cheap. I am wanting some black wood grips for my Sistema.

Gun show in Dallas Market Hall this weekend, come do the touchy-feely thing (with the merchandise) ;-)
-----------
“Sometimes there is no alternative to uncertainty except to await the arrival of more and better data.” C. Wunsch

Venus Pax
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 1
Posts: 3147
Joined: Tue May 16, 2006 5:27 pm
Location: SE Texas

#13

Post by Venus Pax »

I have the Springfield Champion (Commander length) and like it. I sometimes wish I would have gone with the full sized, but I'm fine with it.

I'm paying quite a bit more to have new sights put on it. I hate those dark factory sights. It takes too long to get a sight picture. Take the sights into consideration before making your purchase.

My gun cost me $469 at a gun show. I paid $13 each for two additional magazines. I use this gun for IDPA. I'm paying around $100 for new sights & installation.

Image
"If a man breaks in your house, he ain't there for iced tea." Mom & Dad.

The NRA & TSRA are a bargain; they're much cheaper than the cold, dead hands experience.

BobCat
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 1
Posts: 911
Joined: Wed Dec 29, 2004 3:33 pm
Location: East Bernard, TX

#14

Post by BobCat »

1) I only have one 1911 so am not qualified to make suggestions.

2) It is a Springfield "MIL-SPEC" bought "almost new" several years ago for ~$400. I am amazed if they are really $700 now. All mine needed was the extractor tension adjusted. It has over 6,000 rounds through it and is very reliable and more accurate than I can hold.

3) People say good things about the Rock Island 1911. Many posts on the high road and http://forum.m1911.org/ suggest satisfied shooters.

4) If the color of the grips matters, look around at replacements - they are not expensive. I replaced the black plastic grips on my Springfield with inexpensive wood grips from CDNN http://cdnninvestments.com/19giwagrnew.html and am happy with the sharp checkering and "plain" looks.

Have fun with your new 1911!

Regards,
Andrew
Retractable claws; the *original* concealed carry

TX Rancher
Senior Member
Posts in topic: 2
Posts: 518
Joined: Sun Oct 15, 2006 8:19 am
Location: Fayette Co

#15

Post by TX Rancher »

NcongruNt wrote: While your assessment is generally true, higher cost != higher reliability. In some cases it does, in others not so much. "Performance" and customization play a huge factor here, and I do not find it an unreasonable expectation to expect a $700 pistol with no special features or performance modifications to be reliable for carry duty.
I didn’t make a statement that higher cost always equals higher reliability, I only stated the question should cost be the principle decider for something you may be betting your life on. I personally believe reliability should top the list, but that’s just my personal preference. :grin:

Of course I think it’s prudent to spend the least amount of money required to obtain a reliable pistol, but not less… ;-)
NcongruNt wrote:
In another example, Glocks are known for being reliable guns. They are a favored gun of law enforcement agencies and officers who trust their lives to them every day. Pretty much any of their models can be had for less than $600, plain and stock.
Since I own a G23. G19, and a G26 it would seem I agree with your comments above. I very often carry the 19 and the 26. I’m not as impressed with the 40 Cal as I thought I would be, so it spends a lot of it’s time in the safe…
Post Reply

Return to “General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion”