POSTED: Duck Commander Gift Shop - W. Monroe, LA

[bizarrenormality]

Pennsylvania is one but they also don't criminalize failure to conceal so I'm not sure if that counts.

[JSThane]

I don't know if it's still the case, but weird as it is, I seem to remember Massachusetts does not give a "no guns" sign any force of law...

Granted, -getting- a carry permit there can be harder than pulling hens' teeth, and their "approved firearms roster" is total crap, but once you have it, there's very, very few places you can't take it.

[jmra]

I don't know if it's still the case, but weird as it is, I seem to remember Massachusetts does not give a "no guns" sign any force of law...

Granted, -getting- a carry permit there can be harder than pulling hens' teeth, and their "approved firearms roster" is total crap, but once you have it, there's very, very few places you can't take it.

I'll take Texas gun laws over Massachusetts any day. Think I'll scratch that one off the visit list.

[jmra]

Pennsylvania is one but they also don't criminalize failure to conceal so I'm not sure if that counts.

The corporate offices for a company I worked for many years was in Reading, PA. As I recall other than hunting the area was not pro gun at all. Don't know much about other areas of the state.

[JSThane]

I don't know if it's still the case, but weird as it is, I seem to remember Massachusetts does not give a "no guns" sign any force of law...

Granted, -getting- a carry permit there can be harder than pulling hens' teeth, and their "approved firearms roster" is total crap, but once you have it, there's very, very few places you can't take it.

I'll take Texas gun laws over Massachusetts any day. Think I'll scratch that one off the visit list.

Ya know, funny that, I have no plans on moving there, either, although the wife and I do have kin there and we try to make time to visit.

Just thought it was rather amusing that such a restrictive state has overlooked yet another way to make honest folks into criminals.

[jmra]

I don't know if it's still the case, but weird as it is, I seem to remember Massachusetts does not give a "no guns" sign any force of law...

Granted, -getting- a carry permit there can be harder than pulling hens' teeth, and their "approved firearms roster" is total crap, but once you have it, there's very, very few places you can't take it.

I'll take Texas gun laws over Massachusetts any day. Think I'll scratch that one off the visit list.

Ya know, funny that, I have no plans on moving there, either, although the wife and I do have kin there and we try to make time to visit.

Just thought it was rather amusing that such a restrictive state has overlooked yet another way to make honest folks into criminals.

not sure how they missed that one.

[steveincowtown]

Some things you must remember about La. It is an open carry state for both handguns and long rifles. There is no way to prevent unpermitted open carry without preventing all forms of carry.
So if you want to prevent a Sy character wannabe from walking into the store thinking he is going to show off his toys and his skeet shooting ability to the "family", you have no choice but to put up some kind of no gun sign.

Lessons learned from my 30+ years in La:
- Open carry comes with a price
- Texans don't realize how fortunate they are to have 30.06 signs
- you can't find a decent roast beef po-boy in Texas

JMRA I would have to respectfully disagree.

They are many, states where a No Gun sign has no force of law. You may be asked to leave private property for any reason, which would include if property owner did not like you open carrying. If you were concealed carrying they would have no way to know, and therefor know reason to ask you to leave.

This is much, much better than 30.06. I respect the people who crafted 30.06, and who fought for CC in Texas, but to say we are "lucky" to have 30.06 is only true when compared with states like LA.

Anyhow, I get all my duck dynasty stuff at Academy. Not a single one posted...

Can you list those states for me? Other than Texas of course. I travel some and it would be nice to know the states you are referring to.

JMRA,

Again, IANAL and anyone wanting to confirm the information below should consult with handgunlaw.us, the state which you are visiting, or an attorney in that state (or just stay in a Holiday Inn Express). Here is snip from an old post of mine:

Many states have signs that do not carry the force of law, and I cannot find one case where an owner asking someone to leave resulted in anything else than them leaving.

According to http://www.handgunlaw.us" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false; the following states have laws (or don't have laws depending on how you look at it) that make the "No Guns" sign not have any teeth: (IANAL, do your own research if planning to visit these states):

West Virginia

Virginia

Georgia

Florida

Alabama

Kentucky

Indiana

Iowa

South Dakota

Montana

Colorado

Idaho

Washington

Nevada

Of course not all these states have OC, but this list certainly is long enough that if there was a problem, I am sure it would be all over the liberal news media.

Going back to the premise that most folks who would carry an gun on there hip are the good guys (as the bad guys don't want to be noticed), a store owner should be no more afraid of an armed civilian then anyone else. If we perpetuate the idea that store owners could never confront someone with a gun, I think the unintentional affect of this is giving ammo to the left that people should be afraid of law abiding citizens carry guns.

I don't know for a fact that getting rid of 30.06 and moving us into a situation like the above mentioned states would work here in Texas, but it looks like it is working for them.

I mean this as a polite discussion amongst all members of this board, but 30.06 is broke. If we don't fix it OC will never, ever pass.

There is a valid argument that private property owners in Texas would never tolerate what the folks in the states above have to.

I submit that private property owners don't have to tolerate OC, but what they don't know (ie someone carry concealed) won't hurt them.

[jmra]

So about a fourth of the states on the list. Of course the population of 9 of those states combined is less than the population of Texas.
Having spent some time in some of those states I can tell you that they are not nearly as gun friendly as one would believe.
WV actually has several cities that are allowed to have stricter gun laws than the state. If you live in one of those cities the state gun laws don't mean squat.

Of course you do realize 99% (ok, I pulled that number out of a hat - but you get the point) of the "no gun" signs posted in Texas are not legally enforceable, right?

I don't believe 30.06 is broken at all. I also don't believe 30.06 and OC do or should have anything to do with each other. One of the main reasons we haven't made progress on OC is because some people refuse to accept the aforementioned fact.

[MeMelYup]

I mean this as a polite discussion amongst all members of this board, but 30.06 is broke. If we don't fix it OC will never, ever pass.

There is a valid argument that private property owners in Texas would never tolerate what the folks in the states above have to.

I submit that private property owners don't have to tolerate OC, but what they don't know (ie someone carry concealed) won't hurt them.

Pls explain how you think Texas 30.06 is broken.

[twomillenium]

I also noticed the sign when we stopped in. I probably should have left but I went in because I do not carry any weapons. I do carry a boker pocket knife out of habit and I consider my G30 a tool just like the pocket knife. My boots could be a weapon but I use them to protect my feet just like my G30, it is used to protect my family. I know, I know, I am the kinda guy that keeps Mr. Cotton employed.
I actually noticed it when our visit was complete and I had to go back to the vehicle to fetch a diaper bag for the grandbaby.

[MadMonkey]

More proof it's just an act for free publicity.

Yep. Scripted, and geared toward the hunting crowd who will eat it up because it seems like they share our values. Kind of like WalMart carrying guns, so people think they're on our side.

In both cases, it's all about the money.