Page 1 of 1

Cartridge tumblers for reloading? Which one to buy?

Posted: Sun Nov 11, 2012 7:54 pm
by Moby
Howdy fellas,
I'm getting into reloading and want a good long lasting tumbler that will not break the bank.
I also want something that will tumble at least 200 .308 cases.

Any thoughts?
I want to shoot a lot and pay less to do it!
:fire

Re: Cartridge tumblers for reloading? Which one to buy?

Posted: Sun Nov 11, 2012 8:28 pm
by MoJo
Moby wrote:I want to shoot a lot and pay less to do it!
:fire
Reloading isn't your answer you will shoot a lot and pay about the same to do it. Get a pellet gun if shooting a lot at a lower price is your goal. :coolgleamA:

I have gotten good service out of the Frankfort Arsenal tumblers. I am presently using a Smart Reloader tumbler that does a good job.

Re: Cartridge tumblers for reloading? Which one to buy?

Posted: Sun Nov 11, 2012 8:51 pm
by Oldgringo
MoJo wrote:
Moby wrote:I want to shoot a lot and pay less to do it!
:fire
Reloading isn't your answer you will shoot a lot and pay about the same to do it. Get a pellet gun if shooting a lot at a lower price is your goal. :coolgleamA:
Good advice! FWIW, I really enjoy my various .22 LR long and short guns for extended range time.

I have a Lyman Pro 1200 and a RCBS tumbler for when I decide to reload a few.

Re: Cartridge tumblers for reloading? Which one to buy?

Posted: Sun Nov 11, 2012 9:04 pm
by olafpfj
I've been using a cheap cabelas tumbler. No complaints after 4 years of light use.

Re: Cartridge tumblers for reloading? Which one to buy?

Posted: Sun Nov 11, 2012 9:24 pm
by Moby
MoJo wrote:
Moby wrote:I want to shoot a lot and pay less to do it!
:fire
Reloading isn't your answer you will shoot a lot and pay about the same to do it. Get a pellet gun if shooting a lot at a lower price is your goal. :coolgleamA:
I have gotten good service out of the Frankfort Arsenal tumblers. I am presently using a Smart Reloader tumbler that does a good job.
Forgive me if that makes very little sense.
Perhaps you culd explain?
There are a lot of folks that reload.
If there is no gain in cost of shoting ( WITH THE EXCEPTION OF MATCH GRADE RELOADERS)
Then why do people do it?? You really do not gain in accuracy in pistol ammo as I understand it.

Re: Cartridge tumblers for reloading? Which one to buy?

Posted: Sun Nov 11, 2012 9:41 pm
by Oldgringo
Moby wrote:
MoJo wrote:
Moby wrote:I want to shoot a lot and pay less to do it!
:fire
Reloading isn't your answer you will shoot a lot and pay about the same to do it. Get a pellet gun if shooting a lot at a lower price is your goal. :coolgleamA:
I have gotten good service out of the Frankfort Arsenal tumblers. I am presently using a Smart Reloader tumbler that does a good job.
Forgive me if that makes very little sense.
Perhaps you culd explain?
There are a lot of folks that reload.
If there is no gain in cost of shoting ( WITH THE EXCEPTION OF MATCH GRADE RELOADERS)
Then why do people do it?? You really do not gain in accuracy in pistol ammo as I understand it.
Umm, because they enjoy it and they can...?

Re: Cartridge tumblers for reloading? Which one to buy?

Posted: Sun Nov 11, 2012 10:24 pm
by Middle Age Russ
It is said that reloading will never save you money. It will, however, let you shoot more for the same money.

Re: Cartridge tumblers for reloading? Which one to buy?

Posted: Tue Nov 13, 2012 8:25 pm
by doc540
Middle Age Russ wrote:It is said that reloading will never save you money. It will, however, let you shoot more for the same money.
truth :cheers2:

Re: Cartridge tumblers for reloading? Which one to buy?

Posted: Wed Nov 14, 2012 10:09 am
by Charles L. Cotton
I've used various "small" tumblers over the years and never got more than about 2 years service before something broke. During those years, it ran a lot but I can't give even a reasonable estimate how many hours they typically had on them before failure.

I finally broke down and bought the large Dillon tumbler and it has lasted much longer. Although I don't shoot/reload as much as I once did (little time), the Dillon has many more hours on it than any of its predecessors and it's working fine. It's capacity is also great.

Chas.

Re: Cartridge tumblers for reloading? Which one to buy?

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2012 8:21 am
by Dusty Harry
Ditto on the Dillon - plus anything in Dillon blue comes with that awesome lifetime, no bull warranty.

Re: Cartridge tumblers for reloading? Which one to buy?

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2012 2:27 pm
by PBratton
Moby wrote:
MoJo wrote:
Moby wrote:I want to shoot a lot and pay less to do it!
:fire
Reloading isn't your answer you will shoot a lot and pay about the same to do it. Get a pellet gun if shooting a lot at a lower price is your goal. :coolgleamA:
I have gotten good service out of the Frankfort Arsenal tumblers. I am presently using a Smart Reloader tumbler that does a good job.
Forgive me if that makes very little sense.
Perhaps you culd explain?
There are a lot of folks that reload.
If there is no gain in cost of shoting ( WITH THE EXCEPTION OF MATCH GRADE RELOADERS)
Then why do people do it?? You really do not gain in accuracy in pistol ammo as I understand it.
For me, it's a three stage therapy session:
1. Make bullets
2. Shoot Bullets
3. Goto Step 1