Search found 1 match

by jerry_r60
Tue Mar 11, 2014 11:04 am
Forum: Gun and/or Self-Defense Related Political Issues
Topic: How to Read the Second Amendment
Replies: 15
Views: 2006

Re: How to Read the Second Amendment

Dreamer42 wrote:The original language of the period defines "regulated" as being able to march, knowing the manual of arms, follow orders, readiness, structure of a military command - officers, enlisted, etc. It does not mean regulated in terms of controlled or maintained by a state or federal government like we think of today.
- Dreamer42
:patriot:
I recall watching Antonin Scalia on fox discuss limits to the 2A. He basicly said some of the modern restriction attempts remain to be tested. With that said, he did leave a door open for some limitation. Using the text of the amendment he mentioned limiting guns to what you can carry as an example since the text reads "keep and bear". He also cited a tort on the books at the time called a "frightening". This prevented people walking around with an unusually scary weapon. I could see this concept being pushed in modern times.

I've put a link to the full interview. The whole thing is good and has been linked here before. The begining covers approaches taken to interpreting/applying the constitution. The 2A talk comes about 6:57.

http://therightscoop.com/full-interview ... ws-sunday/" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Return to “How to Read the Second Amendment”