Search found 5 matches

by jocat54
Tue Feb 21, 2012 6:57 pm
Forum: The Crime Blotter
Topic: Man pistol whips Walmart assailants
Replies: 51
Views: 3727

Re: Man pistol whips Walmart assailants

Keith B wrote:
jocat54 wrote: You can call me all the names you want but if you try to harm me or my family, I will try my best to stop you, If that takes shooting you so be it.
Never called you a name. :confused5

I am just trying note that making a blanket statement that anyone who punches you will get shot, period, is a good way to get convicted of manslaughter.

You have now clarified your statement that you will stop them, AND if it takes shooting you, then you will do it. That is now a better viewpoint. And, since you have now stated you are too old to take a single punch, that weighs into the equation. Is your attacker twice your size and half your age? Are there multiple attackers? Is he Mike Tyson? Or is it a little 70 year old mousy women that stands 5 foot tall and is mad because you took the last shopping cart at Walmart and decides to hit you. These are all part of what you must quickly assess before making the decision that anyone punching you will get them shot. Disparity of force HAS to be put into the factors before you make the decision to shoot.

I don't really think that age or size really matters (at least to me).
If someone punches someone else, that makes them an aggressor, don't really care if you are big or old or large or small you are the aggressor and should expect something in return. ???? Yes there is always circumstances--so one must make that decision at the time.

All my answers were taken from the context of the OP,not some little old lady ect.

Just FYI, I am still a fairly large man, 6'2" 190lbs and can still do a lot of what I did when I was younger. (my 65 year old body and my 20 year old mind don't get along very well :mrgreen: )
by jocat54
Tue Feb 21, 2012 9:09 am
Forum: The Crime Blotter
Topic: Man pistol whips Walmart assailants
Replies: 51
Views: 3727

Re: Man pistol whips Walmart assailants

Keith B wrote:
jocat54 wrote: You can call me all the names you want but if you try to harm me or my family, I will try my best to stop you, If that takes shooting you so be it.
Never called you a name. :confused5

I am just trying note that making a blanket statement that anyone who punches you will get shot, period, is a good way to get convicted of manslaughter.

You have now clarified your statement that you will stop them, AND if it takes shooting you, then you will do it. That is now a better viewpoint. And, since you have now stated you are too old to take a single punch, that weighs into the equation. Is your attacker twice your size and half your age? Are there multiple attackers? Is he Mike Tyson? Or is it a little 70 year old mousy women that stands 5 foot tall and is mad because you took the last shopping cart at Walmart and decides to hit you. These are all part of what you must quickly assess before making the decision that anyone punching you will get them shot. Disparity of force HAS to be put into the factors before you make the decision to shoot.
Sorry, I didn't mean you . I was referring to a provoker (attacker) in a situation.
by jocat54
Tue Feb 21, 2012 12:15 am
Forum: The Crime Blotter
Topic: Man pistol whips Walmart assailants
Replies: 51
Views: 3727

Re: Man pistol whips Walmart assailants

Keith B wrote:
jocat54 wrote:
Keith B wrote:
jocat54 wrote:Sorry, but there would have been 2 shot at Walmart---a beating is a beating (and no such thing as fair fight or light punches--if you punch me(lightly or hard) I will try my best to shoot you)
Being too quick on the trigger is worse than being too slow. Without seeing what was happening, you can't make that judgment. A single punch to the body does not necessarily justify use of deadly force and if you jump the gun (no pun intended) you will end up with a charge of manslaughter that you will not beat.
A single punch to the body will get you shot.
Sure hope I never have to serve on a jury where you shot someone for one punch to the body. :roll:

Me To!
I'm just to old to take a punch from anyone. Besides that single punch might be enough to give me a heart attack and kill me.
Besides I don't see where anyone has the right to try to harm anyone--some of you younger guys might be able to take it (and maybe some of the older guys too)
but I have lived long enough that I'm just not going to take it from anyone. You can call me all the names you want but if you try to harm me or my family, I will try my best to stop you, If that takes shooting you so be it.
by jocat54
Mon Feb 20, 2012 10:53 pm
Forum: The Crime Blotter
Topic: Man pistol whips Walmart assailants
Replies: 51
Views: 3727

Re: Man pistol whips Walmart assailants

Keith B wrote:
jocat54 wrote:Sorry, but there would have been 2 shot at Walmart---a beating is a beating (and no such thing as fair fight or light punches--if you punch me(lightly or hard) I will try my best to shoot you)
Being too quick on the trigger is worse than being too slow. Without seeing what was happening, you can't make that judgment. A single punch to the body does not necessarily justify use of deadly force and if you jump the gun (no pun intended) you will end up with a charge of manslaughter that you will not beat.
A single punch to the body will get you shot.
by jocat54
Mon Feb 20, 2012 8:29 pm
Forum: The Crime Blotter
Topic: Man pistol whips Walmart assailants
Replies: 51
Views: 3727

Re: Man pistol whips Walmart assailants

Sorry, but there would have been 2 shot at Walmart---a beating is a beating (and no such thing as fair fight or light punches--if you punch me(lightly or hard) I will try my best to shoot you)

Return to “Man pistol whips Walmart assailants”