Search found 1 match

by Liberty
Sat Jul 28, 2018 6:26 am
Forum: Other States
Topic: HI: 9th Circuit panel rules 2A protects right to carry gun in public
Replies: 33
Views: 10759

Re: HI: 9th Circuit panel rules 2A protects right to carry gun in public

chasfm11 wrote: Thu Jul 26, 2018 4:06 pm "Concealed carry is completely outside the boundaries of the Second Amendment" - Judge in her statement to the lawyer.

Wow, just wow.
I don't believe she was meaning what you think she meant. I think we need to understand the context in which she said that. I believe that she was reffering to the Hawaiian Conceal carry law, in which there has been no one that has to been given a license to carry.

If I understand this correctly. The logic goes something like this.
1: Until this decision Open Carry was illegal.
2: Hawaii has a licensed concealed carry program.
  • a: They have never licenced anyone, never.
    b: Therefore Licensed concealed carry in Hawaii isn't a method that the state allows the 2nd amendment right to carry.
3: The court determined that All Americans have a right to carry
4: If the state has made it impossible for its people to legally conceal carry, The people have the right to open carry,

Return to “HI: 9th Circuit panel rules 2A protects right to carry gun in public”