Interesting in that "lube" is as controversial and opinions based on "feel" more than anything else in general viewer opinion, same as in the Powersport world, auto world and likely porn industry
Through necessity I have used many different "lubes " on Auto light, medium and heavy cal weapons, Semi auto rifles, revolvers, pistols and shot guns.... From vegetable oil to just about every high priced weapon lube on the market 1985 to 2014 and plain old Break Free CLP, WD40, 30wt engine oil and many others. What I found is,,,, they all work to lube......some clean up easier, some are less water resistant, some smell, some don't....some protect better, some attract dirt and sand more.. many need a wet film, some just a barely present almost "dry" layer...and most all lubed about the same. None were miracle fixes for a weapon that had issues...If it had feeding, extracting, other cycling issues it was mostly mechanical (design, wear, damage) and high priced lube or 30wt oil made no difference.
None of that is to say some were not better then another, and after some light research, I just purchased some weapon shield to try on various pistols and a rifle or two.. But the safe queens.. they are lubed and protected with BreakFree CLP.. because I know without a doubt it works. And on a weapon I don't see very often that is my biggest need. KNOW it is protected.