Search found 3 matches

by Beiruty
Wed Apr 25, 2012 10:39 pm
Forum: The Crime Blotter
Topic: Black couple held at gun point by neighbors arrested by PD
Replies: 84
Views: 8386

Re: Black couple held at gun point by neighbors arrested by

Keith B wrote:
matriculated wrote:
Keith B wrote:
Purplehood wrote:I have confronted people in the past that I thought were not where they belonged. Sometimes I was right, sometimes I was wrong. It never became a hostile situation and I never based my assumption on race. After having been in the Military for 24 years you generally look past color when assessing a situation.
I will say straight up I have made those assumptions. There are places that at times are just not right for another race to be.
You know Keith, I've thought long and hard about this. There are those who would reflexively call you racist for the statement that you just made there. Not me. I get it. To begin with, we're all prejudiced to one degree or another, against one group or another. Secondly, life experiences shape our views and prejudices in a way that defies our most idealistic notions about harmony and equality. I understand why cops start profiling after they've been on the job awhile. They notice that black people commit crimes at a higher rate than white people, so they start paying black people more attention. I get that. But there's a sea of difference between paying black people more attention and, say, doing what our friendly neighborhood Batman and Robin did here. There's a sea of difference between paying black people more attention and just simply assuming outright that a black guy you see walking down a street is a criminal (something that George Zimmerman did, as evidenced by his claim that these "[anatomical expletives] always get away." Profiling is a fact of life, and we all do it in different contexts. But common sense has to enter into the equation at some point. That a guy "looks like he's up to no good" is not enough to run out and point a gun in his face. There are plenty of good kids out there who dress and act like gangsters because that's what's prevalent in their peer group and they would be ostracized and thought of as a "loser" if they didn't conform. There are plenty of good kids out there who know perfectly well how to speak proper English but choose to speak the broken, ugly English because that's "cool," and girls are more likely to hang out with you if you talk like that (and if you speak proper, you're said to be "talking white" in a pejorative way). It's a rotten culture to a degree, but none of that gives anyone a right to go out and hold somebody at gunpoint or put a bullet in somebody. I don't know what my exact point is. I guess I'm just spilling a little stream-of-consciousness ink here. I welcome all replies.
Looking at the race of a person in a situation is not nessscarily profiling; it is a factor in the whole picture. A guy in a girls dorm in the middle of the night doesn't belong there. A Jewish person walking in the middle of a Neo-Nazi rally doesn't belong there. An middle-aged white guy like me in the middle of a mosh pit at a punk rock concert doesn't belong there.

Bottom line, discrimination is wrong, period, but race, religion, sex, etc can all play into whether a situation is appropriate or out of bounds.
A conservative Muslim born in the Middle-East, and NRA member with active CHL, looks like I do not belong "there" too. However, I am proud of being a member of both NRA and CHL and this board. :woohoo
by Beiruty
Tue Apr 24, 2012 12:31 pm
Forum: The Crime Blotter
Topic: Black couple held at gun point by neighbors arrested by PD
Replies: 84
Views: 8386

Re: Black couple held at gun point by neighbors arrested by

speedsix wrote:...glad it went well, but what authority did you have to go onto that property and challenge them, demanding that they explain themselves and prove anything to you??? none...it would have been wiser to call the PD and just take down the truck descr., license plate, and their description...from your own property...if they had refused to tell you anything and continued...you would have had to fall back on "call the PD and wait"...why not start with that...and not put yourself in any risk/legal problem...if their response had been different, it could have gotten bad...quick...for a house that you knew to be empty???


...the OP's story illustrates that we MUST learn the laws for ourselves and make our decisions according to law...not casual advice from a LEO whose butt won't be in the frying pan with ours should we act on it...these deputies who slapped 'em on the back after the "hero" episode.........won't likely be standing beside them in court to tell the judge "It's OK, Judge"...sounds like they may be busy down in civil court...we have to know WHAT to do...and be able to explain WHY we did it...according to LAW...or WE will be the ones in trouble...

I was asked many times by the owner to keep an eye on his property. He never disclosed that he would skip payments and let house slide back to the bank. His wife life insurance was a factor to dump his house.

I do agree, calling 911 was the wiser choice. Live and learn, I guess.
by Beiruty
Tue Apr 24, 2012 12:29 am
Forum: The Crime Blotter
Topic: Black couple held at gun point by neighbors arrested by PD
Replies: 84
Views: 8386

Re: Black couple held at gun point by neighbors arrested by

I had the same, exactly the same story. Next door neighbor moved out to Austin after his wife passed away due to advanced cancer. For like a year, the house was empty. One day, I came home, and my wife went like there is a strange truck parked in my neighbor's driveway and 2 shady-looking guys entered from the backyard and they are messing with the rear door with a drill.

My "red-lamps" started flashing! Armed, I got! I approached slowly, sidearm still holstered. And shouted:" Who are you and what are you doing here?" The guys looked the almost :cryin in fear. I hear:" we are the bank-sent contractors to change the keys of this foreclosed house". Never it came to my mind that my neighbor house is foreclosed by a bank. I immediately demanded to see bank papers or order of work issued by the bank. Luckily, those folks, they had 2 red-colored papers that list the ex-owner info and the order to change the locks. It looks said doc was issued by a bank entity.

I verified the info to be correct and the 2-guys finished their work.

No weapons was ever produced, nonetheless, I was in the red-zone.

One thing, I may had to do is call 911. However, I have had asked my wife to call 911 if things went bad in a down hill.

Return to “Black couple held at gun point by neighbors arrested by PD”