Search found 2 matches

by jlangton
Thu Jul 03, 2008 1:26 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Shot placement is more important than caliber but...
Replies: 44
Views: 6328

Re: Shot placement is more important than caliber but...

Excaliber wrote:
In my opinion your better off with a high capacity (7 or 8 shot) 22 LR revolver, loaded with CCI mini-mags that a 25...a 25 is not BG stopper...!
That just might work if the assailants you're planning on dealing with aren't as tough as this 7 year old girl who will be walking around with one of those ferocious man stoppers in her head for the next week until the docs get around to removing it:

http://www.kcra.com/news/16775464/detail.html

She might not have noticed the shot at all when she was hit except for the ear ache it gave her.

Personally, I don't bet my life on that kind of ballistic performance.

If you choose to do so and end up using a .22 to try to resolve a real world encounter with a deadly assailant, please be sure to let us know how it works out .
Terrible comparison. This girl was struck from an unknown distance -at least far enough away that the person shooting was not seen,nor identified. This says NOTHING at all about the ballistics or effectiveness of any particular caliber-esp when comparing their use at defensive distances.
JL
by jlangton
Wed Jul 02, 2008 9:04 am
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Shot placement is more important than caliber but...
Replies: 44
Views: 6328

Re: Shot placement is more important than caliber but...

KBCraig wrote:If she insists on carrying in her purse, then a Desert Eagle .50 --or a brick-- would be more effective than a .25 ACP.

Reason being, her purse swung by the straps is a more effective weapon, especially when it contains something big, heavy, and hard.
So I guess you're willing to stand at arms length(purse swinging length),and allow me to empty a .25 ACP into you to prove this claim?
While I agree that it's not the best caliber to carry,it is better than none at all,and IS more effective than you make it sound.
JL

Return to “Shot placement is more important than caliber but...”