Another suggestion.....
That BCG was NiPH plated by a friend of AndyC's who owns a company that does NiPH plating for the oil field industry, for parts that are subjected to the worst kind of abusive conditions that the industry can hand out (i.e. drill heads, etc.). He did the plating partly as a favor to Andy, and partly because he wanted to see if there might be a new market for his company in plating firearms parts like BCGs.
Is the place where the coating flaked off located on a bearing surface, or is it just on some part of the carrier body that's not in friction contact with other surfaces? If it’s not in contact with other parts, it might be cheaper to just let it go and see what happens. If it is in contact with other parts, then maybe the guy who did the plating in the first place could be persuaded to take another stab at it.....maybe even for free.
Just a thought.
Also, not all AR10s are the same, internally. If you decide to replace the carrier, you want one that will work in a heavy DPMS upper receiver. If the bolt body itself is ok, I would not replace it or the small parts like the firing pin, etc., and only replace the carrier body itself. That bolt was assembled and fitted by Noveske and uses their parts. If the bolt itself is OK, I’d leave it alone.