With that kind of luck, I'd be inclined to replace it with another of the same model.bulletslap wrote:I have received 22 years of good service from a Don Hume IWB leather holster...
Without knowing a bit about your Hume, it's a literal shot in the dark to make a suggestion. What I like in a holster likely won't be right for you. However, I like most of the custom Leather makers, The Milt Sparks Criterion is the reinforced mouth version of the Nexus, which is the most comfy holster I have ever owned. In Kydex, I like JM Custom Kydex for bigger guns and PJ Holsters for little guns. (JM is a bit more expensive than many kydex options but his design and execution is way above the typical bar.)
Here are the things I consider when ordering a holster... What position, what degree of cant, do you prefer a single loop/attachment point or the wide spaced pair, ride height, type of loops or clips, etc.