I don't think this is the best test of whether something is a good SD choice. After all, I am not willing to let someone stab me with a Swiss army knife, but I still think it is a sub-optimal choice as a SD weapon.The Annoyed Man wrote:How about people who call anything not .45 ACP a ‘mouse caliber’, but won’t step in front of one.![]()
Point taken on 9mm vs .45, though. Personally, I carry both. Generally, it is based more on whether I like a particular model of gun, since most of my gun choices only come in one caliber. The only cases where I have made a choice are with my 1911's and my Shield. In both cases, the trade off was between losing one round of capacity for the bigger bullet, and I personally chose the bigger bullet.