Which is exactly what I said.mojo84 wrote:Soccerdad, agree with this statement of yours.I would also add there isn't enough to objectively make a definitive conclusion it wasn't.Unfortunately, there is not enough on that video for me to make a definitive conclusion on whether the shooting was justified.
Search found 6 matches
Return to “Militia standoff going on right now in Oregon!”
- Fri Jan 29, 2016 1:36 pm
- Forum: Off-Topic
- Topic: Militia standoff going on right now in Oregon!
- Replies: 191
- Views: 40334
Re: Militia standoff going on right now in Oregon!
- Fri Jan 29, 2016 1:15 pm
- Forum: Off-Topic
- Topic: Militia standoff going on right now in Oregon!
- Replies: 191
- Views: 40334
Re: Militia standoff going on right now in Oregon!
First off, yes it was an ambush. That is a factual statement, and does not imply judgment as to whether the ambush was right or wrong. A roadblock was set-up on an icy road, around a blind corner. And armed agents of the state were lying in wait in the surrounding woods. All similarly situated roadblocks could be described as ambushes. Not all roadblocks are ambushes, and whether the intended target has violated any laws is irrelevant in determining whether something is an ambush.mojo84 wrote:Here is another good article that provides conflicting info.
http://www.thenewamerican.com/usnews/co ... -by-police
Like I said previously, it "appears" to me he was reaching for something. I made no definitive conclusions. You appear to be the one that has though.
Based on your comments, I guess all roadblocks of people that have been breaking the law are "ambushes".
There is no one on here harder oncops when are obviously in the wrong than me. I have even been erroneously accused of being anticop. In this instance, we have people that have been breaking the law, wouldn't stop for the cops so a roadblock was set up and it APPEARS the guy was shot after reaching for something on the left side of his body. I believe based on these three things and if one objectively looks at this, it APPEARS the shooting MAY have been justified.
Soccerdad, I fully understand who we are talking about. Do you understand we are talking about armed peoplofficehave been illegally occupying a government office and didn't stop for the police like the other vehicle did? Haven't we discussed on here before that a charging vehicle is a deadly threat. A vehicle not stopping at a road block MAY be justification to shoot.
Have we all become so jaded and cynical we just can't objectively evaluate what we see?
And second, I am trying to objectively evaluate what I can see from the video, which isn't a whole lot. I cannot objectively determine that the shooting victim was reaching for anything, nor can I objectively determine that he was reaching toward a specific pocket. I can say that whether he actually had a weapon in a given location is less relevant than whether the shooter reasonably believed that he was reaching for a weapon. Unfortunately, there is not enough on that video for me to make a definitive conclusion on whether the shooting was justified.
- Fri Jan 29, 2016 1:02 pm
- Forum: Off-Topic
- Topic: Militia standoff going on right now in Oregon!
- Replies: 191
- Views: 40334
Re: Militia standoff going on right now in Oregon!
I agree. If someone lies. They are a liar. That does not mean they are lying every time they speak. It does mean that a reasonable person should be suspicious every time they speak.Javier730 wrote:Alot of police officers have been caught lying, that does not mean you can call the entire agency liars everytime they speak.Soccerdad1995 wrote:We are talking about a government agency that has been shown to be dishonest in the past. When dealing with a known liar, it is not biased or tainted to assume that they might be lying yet again. It is logical.mojo84 wrote:I appreciate your response but I do think we need to look at this stuff objectively and not through the tainted lens that the cops are always wrong and there's a big conspiracy and cover-up behind every event.
And I would never assume that a police officer, politician, or lawyer (among others) was ever telling me the truth.
- Fri Jan 29, 2016 12:40 pm
- Forum: Off-Topic
- Topic: Militia standoff going on right now in Oregon!
- Replies: 191
- Views: 40334
Re: Militia standoff going on right now in Oregon!
We are talking about a government agency that has been shown to be dishonest in the past. When dealing with a known liar, it is not biased or tainted to assume that they might be lying yet again. It is logical.mojo84 wrote:I appreciate your response but I do think we need to look at this stuff objectively and not through the tainted lens that the cops are always wrong and there's a big conspiracy and cover-up behind every event.
- Fri Jan 29, 2016 11:28 am
- Forum: Off-Topic
- Topic: Militia standoff going on right now in Oregon!
- Replies: 191
- Views: 40334
Re: Militia standoff going on right now in Oregon!
The road looked a bit icy.Javier730 wrote:His brake pedal would of worked better at avoiding the collision.parabelum wrote:As he approaches the blockade, Mr. Finicum clearly swerves to the left to avoid colliding with the patrol units.
The vehicles not being in the road would have worked even better at avoiding a collision.
- Fri Jan 29, 2016 11:20 am
- Forum: Off-Topic
- Topic: Militia standoff going on right now in Oregon!
- Replies: 191
- Views: 40334
Re: Militia standoff going on right now in Oregon!
His hand went down, but I don't think the video is conclusive on exactly where his hand was or if was reaching for anything versus trying to maintain his balance. Without knowing exactly what he was being told to do it is tough to determine whether he was complying with orders.mojo84 wrote:It appears to me he reached for something under his jacket on the left side. I am on my phone and the picture is small but I think he could have been carrying a gun in the cross draw position and he reached for it.
Has it been reported there was a gun on him and where it was?
And I agree that the officer who jumped in front of a moving vehicle does not appear to be the sharpest tool in the shed.