TexasCHLforum.com

NotRPB

NotRPB wrote:
Soccerdad1995 wrote:I was just getting ready to buy some fire extinguishers for the house this weekend. This is very timely info.
I just bought 2 more yesterday too, spent entire day finding best UL rating for 5 and 10 lb for the price

great tool here to compare UL rating by size, then search for your best price wherever
https://www.grainger.com/category/fire- ... dsZ1yyy0oo

5lb
5lb Buckeye 10914 ABC Dry Chemical 3A:40B:C
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B009W ... UTF8&psc=1
$61.00 Free Shipping no tax

10lb
10lb ABC Dry Chemical
Amerex B456 4A:80B:C
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00CM ... UTF8&psc=1
$62.99 free shipping no tax

So a 2 dollars more for higher UL rated 10 lb 4A:80B:C than a 5 lb 3A:40B:C ( I still got 1 of each, so a kid could lift)
that 10lb can cover 80 square feet, that 5 lb can cover 40 square feet

Similar, second choice 10lb is First Alert Pro 10 ... UL Rating 4A:60B:C (Lower UL rating 60 instead of 80 and it costs more) so THAT 10lb weighs as much, but only covers 60 Square feet instead of 80, and it costs more!
https://www.google.com/search?ei=Xcr8WZ ... r8E5W1N86U

(All 5 lbs are'nt created equal, all 10lbs aren't created equal etc... I don't know why since weight and dry material used is the same, but UL rated them, not me)
almost bought a 20lb because they go can up to 60A:120BC but that's a bit heavy

ABC explained:
Class A fires Ordinary Combustibles: wood, paper, cloth, trash and other ordinary materials
Class B fires Flammable Liquids & Gases such as gasoline, oils, paint lacquer and tar
Class C fires involving live electrical equipment

UL Rating explained:
Simplified :
the 1 2 3 4 5 6 10 20 40 60 80 120
Higher numbers are better

These numerical ratings allow you to compare the relative extinguishing effectiveness of various fire extinguishers. For example, an extinguisher that is rated 4A:20B:C indicates the following:
1. The A rating is a water equivalency rating.
Each A is equivalent to 1 1/4 gallons of water. 4A = 5 gallons of water.

2. The B:C rating is equivalent to the amount of square footage that the extinguisher can cover, handled by a professional.
20 B:C = 20 square feet of coverage.

3. C indicates it is suitable for use on electrically energized equipment

Newegg Marketplace (Zoro) also has a good price on the 5lb 10914, Buckeye 3A40BC better price ($48.98 +$5 shipping = $53.98 total) than Amazon ($61.00)(which I received) so I bought yet another for another room
https://www.newegg.com/Product/Product. ... gnorebbr=1

NotRPB

How I finally found the most extinguisher for the $

searched, then saw shipping and/or tax added to price versus what i saw with free shipping and tax elsewhere)
highest UL rated 5lb ABC extinguisher

highest UL rated 10lb ABC extinguisher

(Buckeye/Badger/Amerex brands [ made in USA I believe, instead of out of Country like some others ] are high UL rated for each size/money, lots of commercial restaurants/businesses use them, First Alert is good, but more expensive, I'm guessing some people pay for name recognition since home consumers buy their smoke detectors etc more)

I have no affiliation with those companies, just sharing what I spent a full day researching

NotRPB

They're recalling several sizes, but ... THE kIDDE i HAVE GOT RECALLED IS A 2.5 LB 1A-10BC
1A >>> (equal to 2 gallon of water to put out a fire in garbage can was not enough)

It was a replacement to a 2.5 lb one that was used to try to stop a fire in a neighbor's plastic garbage can when they emptied an ashtray in it, then went to work ... it was too small and ran out before the fire was out, but they bought me a replacement the same size as what I used up.

Since it was too small is why I'm buying the 5lb (3A = 4 gallons Water 40B:C (40 square feet coverage for liquid fires) and 10lb (4A=5gallons water 80B:C 80 Square feet coverage for Liquid fires) because we have a volunteer fire Dept and I don't know their average response time, but it took a while so I had to drag the flaming melting garbage can out from under their carport to an open area in the driveway after the extinguisher was empty

so I'll have 3 now, the replacement 2.5lb 1A:10BC "too small to put out a small garbage can fire" for the recalled one the neighbors bought me. and the 3A:40BC and 4A:80BC ones I ordered above so next garbage can fire they have I may can extinguish it instead of dragging a flaming melting can around breathing fumes hoping the aerosol cans in there don't explode on me (one did, like a can of bug spray they had in there, the oils in aerosol bug spray exploding quickly re-ignited the thing according to Fireman Investigator man)

NotRPB

Soccerdad1995 wrote:I was just getting ready to buy some fire extinguishers for the house this weekend. This is very timely info.

I just bought 2 more yesterday too, spent entire day finding best UL rating for 5 and 10 lb for the price

great tool here to compare UL rating by size, then search for your best price wherever
https://www.grainger.com/category/fire- ... dsZ1yyy0oo

5lb
5lb Buckeye 10914 ABC Dry Chemical 3A:40B:C
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B009W ... UTF8&psc=1
$61.00 Free Shipping no tax

10lb
10lb ABC Dry Chemical
Amerex B456 4A:80B:C
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00CM ... UTF8&psc=1
$62.99 free shipping no tax

So a 2 dollars more for higher UL rated 10 lb 4A:80B:C than a 5 lb 3A:40B:C ( I still got 1 of each, so a kid could lift)
that 10lb can cover 80 square feet, that 5 lb can cover 40 square feet

Similar, second choice 10lb is First Alert Pro 10 ... UL Rating 4A:60B:C (Lower UL rating 60 instead of 80 and it costs more) so THAT 10lb weighs as much, but only covers 60 Square feet instead of 80, and it costs more!
https://www.google.com/search?ei=Xcr8WZ ... r8E5W1N86U

(All 5 lbs are'nt created equal, all 10lbs aren't created equal etc... I don't know why since weight and dry material used is the same, but UL rated them, not me)
almost bought a 20lb because they go can up to 60A:120BC but that's a bit heavy

ABC explained:
Class A fires Ordinary Combustibles: wood, paper, cloth, trash and other ordinary materials
Class B fires Flammable Liquids & Gases such as gasoline, oils, paint lacquer and tar
Class C fires involving live electrical equipment

UL Rating explained:
Simplified :
the 1 2 3 4 5 6 10 20 40 60 80 120
Higher numbers are better

These numerical ratings allow you to compare the relative extinguishing effectiveness of various fire extinguishers. For example, an extinguisher that is rated 4A:20B:C indicates the following:
1. The A rating is a water equivalency rating.
Each A is equivalent to 1 1/4 gallons of water. 4A = 5 gallons of water.

2. The B:C rating is equivalent to the amount of square footage that the extinguisher can cover, handled by a professional.
20 B:C = 20 square feet of coverage.

3. C indicates it is suitable for use on electrically energized equipment

NotRPB

My new replacement is on its way. Mine was recalled. The recall affects some models going back to 1973 up to 2017.

See https://s3.amazonaws.com/inmar-adx-file ... +Kidde.pdf

for more info

TexasCHLforum.com

Search found 5 matches

Re: Kiddee fire extinguisher recall

Re: Kiddee fire extinguisher recall

Re: Kiddee fire extinguisher recall

Re: Kiddee fire extinguisher recall

Re: Kiddee fire extinguisher recall