Revolver Vs. Semi Auto And Why?

[carlson1]

BUT, now that I have found the love of my life: i.e. H&K P7, that is what I'll have on around town from now on.

I should shoot my friend who traded me a HK P7 PSP. I went and traded some other pistols and I now have a P7 M13. I think they are the greatest. Just my opinion.

[age_ranger]

I carry a semi-auto. I prefer the higher magazine capacity and function of the semi-suto. Although the revolvers are simple to operate and can be very light and concealable, I find the semi-auto's (some) just as reliable and better overall for ME. I think it comes down to personal preference because I see both being reliable, concealable, accurate and able to store a sufficient number of rounds.

The one thing I'd like to point out is that recoil on the semi-auto's is noticeably lighter which I also prefer.

[casselthief]

and even better with a backup handgun and AR15...

how do you hide that AR15 under yer shirt???

[Roger Howard]

SA, I like the capicity. 16+1 and two spare mags= 49. Ok, Ok a little over kill (pardon the pun). I also like wheel guns but don't currently own one but I'm planning on changing that ASAP.

[Scroggwe]

I voted both. I've had my CHL less than a year and only recently started carrying regularly. I've been carrying a Taurus M85 .38 Spl. as I thought my S&W M&P40 was too big. I just finished wearing the M&P40 for three days and found it comfortable and easily concealed if I dress around it (hawaiian shirts or extra large shirts).

[catsofthebase3]

I'm new to the CHL game too. Usual carry is a Kimber fullsize IWB, but it gets hot and my t-shirts hug a bit. So now i have a S&W 360 in my pocket. Weather permitting, I can have two guns, and an extra mag for the Kimber.

[Piney]

Greetings--

I chose a semi due to
1) the round capacity and
2) its ease of reloading(for me)

[Venus Pax]

I chose the SA since it's thinner.

[jclif1995]

currently a 6904 in my manbag. i am waiting on a 442 and will use a pocket holster with this wheel gun.

[Stephen A. Camp]

Hello. I voted "both." My "always gun" is a Model 642 carried in a pocket holster. When I carry a concealed belt gun and it's not a revolver, it is either a 9mm Hi Power or .45 in the 1911 type semiauto.

Best.

[CHL/LEO]

George posted:

...because I never, ever, ever shot an automatic I could trust.

I'm curious as to what type of SA handguns that you've had issues with and what type of problems they've been?

[CWOOD]

I carry a Glock 30 IWB.

I carried a S&W M28 while in DPS...that tells you how long ago that was. I really liked that. I still have a Ruger Security Six that I bought new when they first came out...S/N 150-xxxxx. Great revolver.

Have had 1911's and loved those but the G-30 works well for me and I love .45ACP. 10+1 plus 13 more on those occarions when I carry an extra mag.

For the rare occasions when I need for DEEP concealment, East German Makarov in a Kramer Confidant undershirt.

Jeez, I like them all.

[BoneDigger]

Up until I recently purchased my S&W 686 with a 2.5 inch barrel I was a died-in-the-wool auto fan. Now I like both. I would carry either with no hesitation.

BTW, my auto is a Taurus PT145.

Todd