I'm a dyed-in-the-wool 1911 fan. I have several and thats the best platform I know. That said, I broke down and bought an XD45 a couple of months ago, and I have to say that if I didn't already have a thing for 1911's, I'd probably think the XD was the greatest thing since sliced bread. My perception is that there is vitually no difference in felt recoil.flintknapper wrote:Those with XD's in .45 with 4" barrel, how do they compare in terms of felt recoil to a 1911 with similar barrel length?
The reason I ask... is that I'm still wrestling with what weapon to get my daughter for concealed carry this spring/summer. She shoots my commander length 1911 fine, but the XD may be different.
I don't want to get her a .40 because I have yet to shoot one (any make) that didn't feel pretty "snappy" in recoil. That leaves 9mm (manageable recoil, high capacity) but I'd rather see her with a .45 if the chips are down.
She is an experienced shooter (started her at 9) although she hasn't shot recently. I am not worried about her being able to handle an XD-45 if it compares favorably to a 1911.
I know recoil perception is a subjective thing, but what are your thoughts anyway.
Thanks,
Flint.
I doubt she would have any problem with one, from what you said.