I guess that's why we have appeals courts.srothstein wrote:I think we may have some trouble with the definition of a private vehicle. I fully agree that any governmental vehicle is not private, but I am nto sure about all commercial vehicles. The ones I think they did not want to allow carrying in are vehicles for hire, such as busses and taxis.
It would be nice in the first instance if the legislature wrote laws as they intended. They could have written "vehicles owned, leased, or rented by a natural person,*" or "privately owned vehicles other than common carriers."
Even with taxis, the taxi driver is not controlled by the paying passenger, other than going to the requested destination. If a peace officer stops the taxi for a violation of traffic law, the passengers have no part in that; and there is little basis for questioning or searching them.
Commercial buses such as Greyhound are another story. Their passengers are second-class citizens.
*I have no idea whether "natural person" is a concept in Texas law.
- Jim