OK -- I'll try one more time, then I'll give up.Ameer wrote:There's only one POTUS at a time. No matter who you individually voted for, "we" all elected Obama.sjfcontrol wrote:So, a (presumed) republican voting in the 2008 election for "none of the above", would have elected, who exactly? (We were talking elections, not armed robberies.)Ameer wrote:That's provably wrong and it's the type of thinking that got us in this mess. If a mugger gives you the choice of "your money or your life" and you choose the lesser evil, the mugger wins because you let him limit your choices. A smarter choice might be "none of the above" in the form of fighting back, escaping, or something else that doesn't benefit evil.sjfcontrol wrote:Of course you realize: "Those that don't vote for the lesser of two evils, vote for the greater"Purplehood wrote:
I won't be voting for the lesser of two evils. I did that last time with John McCain despite my severe reservations about him.
Fighting the mugger doesn't work all the time, but it's a better choice in the long run.
1) We are not talking about muggers -- or at least I wasn't. I/We are talking about elections.
2) Once you get to the full election, you typically have a choice between a Republican and a Democrat. Looking at the 2008 election from the perspective of someone who wanted to promote the conservative agenda, we had a choice between a weak conservative republican -- McCain, and a Socialist Democrat, Obama.
Now anybody who took the attitude "I will not vote for the lesser of two evils" (i.e., McCain), is left with a choice between voting for Obama, voting for a third-party or write-in candidate who simply cannot win, or not voting at all. I state that ANY of those choices simply accrue to the advantage of Obama, the "greater" evil.
If you'd like to argue that we need stronger republican candidates -- I whole heartedly AGREE! But once you get to the day of the election, you're stuck with the candidates you have.
3) Although "WE" may have all elected Obama, I'd like to think I did my part to see that he didn't win.