Search found 4 matches

by pbwalker
Wed Jul 14, 2010 6:22 pm
Forum: General Texas CHL Discussion
Topic: Utah CHL Instructor Story on WFAA
Replies: 231
Views: 32351

Re: Utah CHL Instructor Story on WFAA

joe817 wrote:
The Annoyed Man wrote:
fishcharmer wrote:Let the flaming begin.
Naaahhh. I like sushi. :mrgreen:
Raw fish?? Ewwwwwww. Fried catfish for me TYVM. :drool:
ooohhh...now I'm hungry. I could go for some nigiri or sashimi! :drool:

oh, and to keep it on topic: I love guns and have been to Utah before. ;-)
by pbwalker
Sat Jun 26, 2010 10:39 pm
Forum: General Texas CHL Discussion
Topic: Utah CHL Instructor Story on WFAA
Replies: 231
Views: 32351

Re: Utah CHL Instructor Story on WFAA

Charles L. Cotton wrote: You can't be serious. Are you really going to argue that someone who takes a class on Texas law is not more knowledgeable about Texas law than someone who takes a class on Utah law?
Well, yes...because its an assumption on your part. Would you say that ALL TX CHL students / licensees are well versed on the law? I wouldn't...when there are TX CHLers can't even grasp the concept of a 30.06 sign.
pbwalker wrote:It is the responsibility of the CHL/CFP holder to know the laws of the state they are in, regardless of the license. Are you saying that non-resident CHLers are not as up on the law as resident CHLers?
Charles L. Cotton wrote: Yes, I'm saying that a resident from another state who comes to Texas and carries on their state's license is not as "up on [Texas] law as a [Texas] resident" who took a Texas CHL class.

Chas.
Again, that's an assumption / opinion. Rest assured, when I travel to Florida or Arizona, I will know the laws. I would expect the same from anyone who comes here. There's too much risk involved in not doing so...
by pbwalker
Sat Jun 26, 2010 10:22 pm
Forum: General Texas CHL Discussion
Topic: Utah CHL Instructor Story on WFAA
Replies: 231
Views: 32351

Re: Utah CHL Instructor Story on WFAA

Charles L. Cotton wrote:
pbwalker wrote:
Charles L. Cotton wrote:
Significant Otter wrote:On the whole, Texans with a Utah CFP seem to be at least as knowledgeable and competent as those who pass one of the many "One Day CHL" classes taught in Texas.
What is the basis of this statement? What evidence supports this rather outrageous opinion of approximately 450,000 Texas CHL holders about 1600 CHL Instructors?

Chas.
What's outrageous about the statement? My class was one day. I had many choices of CHL instructors.
It's outrageous to argue that someone who takes only a Utah CHP class is as knowledgeable about Texas law as someone who takes a Texas CHL course. The Utah course does not and cannot teach Texas law.
pbwalker wrote:Are Texans with Utah CFP licenses NOT as knowledgeable as Texans with TX CHLs?

I must be missing something..
Correct, see above.

Chas.
Aren't you making assumptions there? What evidence do you have that supports this?

It is the responsibility of the CHL/CFP holder to know the laws of the state they are in, regardless of the license. Are you saying that non-resident CHLers are not as up on the law as resident CHLers?

I'm sorry, but based on some of the questions I have seen here (from newbie CHLers), I'd argue that even TX CHLers are not that knowledgeable of the law...

not being argumentative here...just trying to understand your thought on this...

full disclosure, I don't have any out of state CHL/CFP.
:tiphat:
by pbwalker
Sat Jun 26, 2010 9:40 pm
Forum: General Texas CHL Discussion
Topic: Utah CHL Instructor Story on WFAA
Replies: 231
Views: 32351

Re: Utah CHL Instructor Story on WFAA

Charles L. Cotton wrote:
Significant Otter wrote:On the whole, Texans with a Utah CFP seem to be at least as knowledgeable and competent as those who pass one of the many "One Day CHL" classes taught in Texas.
What is the basis of this statement? What evidence supports this rather outrageous opinion of approximately 450,000 Texas CHL holders about 1600 CHL Instructors?

Chas.
What's outrageous about the statement? My class was one day. I had many choices of CHL instructors. Are Texans with Utah CFP licenses NOT as knowledgeable as Texans with TX CHLs?

I must be missing something...

Return to “Utah CHL Instructor Story on WFAA”