Search found 3 matches

by ScottDLS
Fri Jun 03, 2011 6:18 pm
Forum: Gun and/or Self-Defense Related Political Issues
Topic: TSA Threatens to Shut Down All Texas Air Travel
Replies: 98
Views: 13676

Re: TSA Threatens to Shut Down All Texas Air Travel

Katygunnut wrote:
Scott in Houston wrote:
Katygunnut wrote:
Texas (or any other state) has the ability to secede if we want to. The only question is whether the government of that neighboring country (the USA) would try to stop us.

Kind of like saying that I have the ability to withhold my Federal income tax check. I just need to have the backbone to live with the consequences of that action.
Now we're splitting hairs aren't we?

I was referencing the myth that Texas can, without any resistance from the Fed Govt, secede because we entered the union as a sovereign nation, so we can leave as one. There are people who legitimately believe this to be true, when it is not.
My point was that Texas does not need the US Governments permission to leave the union. Personally, I'm not sure whether the US Gubmint would try to stop Texas with force or not, but if the citizens of Texas decided to make the move, then I'm not sure it would practically matter much whether it was legal or not. Call me cynical, but I don't think our Federal gubmint much cares about the laws that are supposed to restrict their actions.
Wasn't it tried circa 1861-1865...and didn't work out too well. :???:
by ScottDLS
Wed May 25, 2011 9:30 pm
Forum: Gun and/or Self-Defense Related Political Issues
Topic: TSA Threatens to Shut Down All Texas Air Travel
Replies: 98
Views: 13676

Re: TSA Threatens to Shut Down All Texas Air Travel

Beiruty wrote:Don't Texas have Sexual Assult law? Sure. Look it up. It is a felony too. Fondling (touching private parts) of a child is a felony.
Yes, that's the law that the bill was trying to amend to make it clear that it applied to TSA. Idaho has a law against murder and tried to invoke it in Ruby Ridge case, but ultimately lost to the Feds.
by ScottDLS
Wed May 25, 2011 8:18 pm
Forum: Gun and/or Self-Defense Related Political Issues
Topic: TSA Threatens to Shut Down All Texas Air Travel
Replies: 98
Views: 13676

Re: TSA Threatens to Shut Down All Texas Air Travel

The ever expanding police power of the national government has been an issue dating at least to Prohibtion and arguably to Reconstruction. Also, the US Attorney's letter was heavy handed and is a thinly veiled bluff. The legislation wouldn't have taken effect until 9/1/2011 with plenty of time to get a stay of its enforcement from a federal judge. Additionally the TSA & US Attorney are bluffing because Texas could very easily get an injunction (in Federal court) to block the TSA from this action while this issue was being litigated.

That said...I have posted from the beginning that this bill was a bad idea. It is a clear violation of the supremacy clause of the US constitution. Some may pine for the days of the Republic and the Confederacy (I don't), but the bill would have accomplished nothing since it was going to be struck down anyway. I think the TSA pat downs are ridiculous and open to challenge on 4th amendment grounds, but it is established precedent that States may not interfere with Federal officials performing constitutionally authorized duties. If you want to argue that pat downs are not constitutional, you have to fight it at the Federal level on 4th amendment grounds or maybe 10th amendment grounds (i.e. Argue Feds are not authorized to regulate the security of air travel...that's a tough sell, especially interstate).

Now we've taken "precious" legislative time to mess with this, that could have been spent on Campus Carry or Parking Lot Bill....I mean goodness, we barely sneaked Noodling through... :roll:

Return to “TSA Threatens to Shut Down All Texas Air Travel”