Search found 3 matches

by Keith B
Thu Dec 04, 2008 4:32 pm
Forum: 2009 Texas Legislative Session
Topic: Do you think unlicensed Open-Carry will pass in Texas?
Replies: 40
Views: 6956

Re: Do you think unlicenses Open-Carry will pass in Texas?

Liko81 wrote:
Keith B wrote:Liko81, I would like to ask how many times have you 'open carried'? I'm not talking about out on the farm, deer lease or on your own property, but in public with a lot of folks around?
On two seperate occasions; I have grandparents in Phoenix, and while shopping last Christmas I decided to do so OCing. I noticed one slightly uncomfortable look from a passerby, and a cashier asked what type of gun it was; he OCed regularly but his employer forbade carry on the job. A third person made the joke, "well sure it's legal, but this ain't Texas!", to which I replied "and thank goodness, because if I were doing this there I'd be arrested" :banghead:. The other one was a reunion with the other half of my family in Virginia. Didn't get a second glance or mention; the hotel check-in person asked if I would prefer to put it in their vault, to which I politely declined and he smiled and made no further mention. That's not to mention several times I've camped out at a friend's lake lot with my .22 at my side for snakes, and of course it's on my hip in my apartment after a particular episode involving a very drunk neighbor that I've told before.
I also meant to post: It looks like you have had a couple of experiences with OC and did experience the looks. I would be willing to bet most pushing for it have never open carried anywhere in public.

IIRC, Arizona or Virginia have never had a law against it, so they may be more used to seeing OC than other states. Take that to a state where it has never been legal (at least in our lifetime) and it will be ten-fold the looks and fear.

I also didn't mention another aspect that will be a problem; profiling. Let's face it, it's human nature. Many folks go by first appearances. If someone like me (middle aged, short hair, clean cut, business casual dress, super good looking :biggrinjester:) walks in somewhere with a hog leg on my hip, people will not be as concerned. However, take a guy in faded jeans, with tattoos, long hair, beard, biker t-shirt and vest riding a Harley (just an example), they many times already have a preconceived idea he is a member of a biker gang. Add a gun on his side and you have just lit their panic fuse. Now, he may be the nicest guy in the world, and i may be another Jack the Ripper, but the first look tells them differently. We could both be legally carrying, but who do you think will get called on?

I think if open carry does pass, there will be so many ways to prohibit it (signs or worse, like Missouri, municipal variances over state law banning it) that it will be a nightmare for gun owners.

Again, just my opinion. That and $4.50 will buy you a small cup of coffee at Starbucks! ;-)
by Keith B
Thu Dec 04, 2008 3:57 pm
Forum: 2009 Texas Legislative Session
Topic: Do you think unlicensed Open-Carry will pass in Texas?
Replies: 40
Views: 6956

Re: Do you think unlicenses Open-Carry will pass in Texas?

Liko81 wrote: And about "intentionally" failing to conceal; that one word is the ONLY thing that keeps you from going to jail if you bend over and print, or your shirt blows up in a sudden gust of wind.
I think my point was not made well; if you remove the 'intentional' and make it a defense to prosecution if they have a CHL and fail to conceal. However, that would pretty well make open carry legal for a CHL then wouldn't it! :lol:
by Keith B
Thu Dec 04, 2008 2:35 pm
Forum: 2009 Texas Legislative Session
Topic: Do you think unlicensed Open-Carry will pass in Texas?
Replies: 40
Views: 6956

Re: Do you think unlicenses Open-Carry will pass in Texas?

Liko81 wrote:I cannot believe you guys. Those who say it probably won't because it's such a flying leap all at once, probably have good standing to say so, and I applaud your honesty even as I tell you to have a little optimism. Those who say it won't for any other reason have generally given a reason in the "I don't think it should" category. What unbelievable hypocrisy; many of you fought for concealed carry, but now that you have what you want you won't fight to not have to have government permission to exercise a constitutional right. Parking lot carry, concealed carry on campus, definition of a "school" to exclude private institutions, all these are pebbles in a mountain of restrictions and infringements heaped on the Second Amendment, and you're picking away at it with a toothpick. You'll get a lot farther by dynamiting the top of the hill off.

Here's one reason that more concealed carry "rights" won't make a bit of difference in the Second Amendment fight overall; no matter where you can carry, as long as that gun is concealed, NOBODY KNOWS YOU HAVE IT. A third of the residents in Texas, the entire lawful gun-owning population of the State, could have CHLs and be carrying right now, and I guarantee you the rest of Texas residents wouldn't know anyone actually carried a gun around on a daily basis. Show your gun, and now people know that some of them go armed, far more than they thought. OC is thus educational. CCers work very hard not to be "outed". OCers out themselves every day. Why? because a CCer is walking a fine line between being armed for their protection, and being "normal". OCers reject the notion of there being a difference; there is no reason carrying a holstered handgun is anything other than "normal" no matter how few do so regularly. There are a lot of subgroups that make up 1% or fewer of the population of the U.S.; is there somehow something abnormal and "fringe" about having a Ph.D? How about living in a state other than the 21 most populous (making your state's population less than 5 million and therefore less than 1% of the U.S. population)? I could go on, but I think you get my point; no matter how much a minority, whether something is "fringe" and therefore not "normal" depends solely on public perception, not how small a minority. And you're never going to change public perception by sticking to "out of sight, out of mind".

I'll go a step further; it is your civil right to carry a defensive weapon of your choice. To require you to pay money to be granted permission to exercise it is equivalent to paying a poll tax or paying the court to have a jury trial (if you're found not guilty the State eats court costs).
Liko81,

I would like to ask how many times have you 'open carried'? I'm not talking about out on the farm, deer lease or on your own property, but in public with a lot of folks around? I can bet to say the majority of those who are fighting so hard for open carry have never done it, and just want it because they think it would be easier. It is a novel concept, and if it was something that had never been outlawed, might work. However, as one who has open carried in public where it is legal and has never been outlawed, the general populace give you funny looks and is VERY leery of you. Trust me on this one. There are many stories of open carry states where the police get called because someone has a gun hanging on their belt and the police have to respond when called. The person carrying the gun is told to leave and they have to do it. You will also find that if it does get legalized, there would be a method for the stores and other locations to prohibit carry. It would probably NOT be a 30.06 sign or variant, but just a gunbuster or 'no guns' sign of any kind. You put that in Texas and in a HEAVILY populated area and, even if legal and publicized, you are going to get a lot of flack and be banned from almost every locale.

I think trying to go from outlawed to legal is probably not going to get passed. It's just a reality, not negativity IMO. I just hope that it doesn't put too much negative emphasis on the other gun related items that, IMO, have a real possibility of getting passed. I would much prefer a re-write of the statute that does away with the word 'intentionally' in the 'fails to conceal' wording.

This is just my view, and does not reflect the views of my employer (who won't let me carry either! :banghead: )

Return to “Do you think unlicensed Open-Carry will pass in Texas?”