Search found 3 matches

by Soccerdad1995
Thu Apr 19, 2018 11:27 am
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Dick's Sporting Goods to destroy all unsold firearms after Parkland shooting
Replies: 34
Views: 10523

Re: Dick's Sporting Goods to destroy all unsold firearms after Parkland shooting

Liberty wrote:I am a simple man and not an economist but let me see if I understand this correctly.
  • This Dick company owns some AR15s.
    They are opposed to people having the right to own them and wants them unavailable.
    The Destroy all their stock of these weapons of mass destruction.
    These weapons are paid for even though they were never in the public hands.
    The manufactures made their money and people will buy their new AR15s from other places
    This is a profitable action for the gun makers. Destroying the weapons is a minute boost for the gun industry
Unintended consequences. The harder the leftist try, the more they boost the firearms industry.
Yes, basically the gun manufacturers get to sell each gun twice. Instead of them selling one gun to Dick's that is then sold on to an end customer, they sell one gun to Dick's, and then sell a second gun to the end customer. Net result is a wealth transfer from Dicks shareholders to the gun manufacturers, and no reduction in the number of guns available for civilians.

Dick's action does make small minded people "feel" better though. Usually these people are incapable of using logic, so they don't understand the idiocy of their actions. It is rare to see such unintelligent people advance to positions where they are running publicly traded corporations, but I think we now know why Dicks stock is tanking relative to their peers. Like I said, I would expect a shareholder lawsuit to be filed at some point.
by Soccerdad1995
Wed Apr 18, 2018 12:53 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Dick's Sporting Goods to destroy all unsold firearms after Parkland shooting
Replies: 34
Views: 10523

Re: Dick's Sporting Goods to destroy all unsold firearms after Parkland shooting

puma guy wrote:Destroying the weapons is all about the publicity. They could have quietly donated them to law enforcement and even if they didn't consider that an option they could have quietly destroyed them. Instead they make a big deal out of it to garner some additional publicity now that the initial fanfare has waned along with their sales and stock. Perhaps they think they'll get some additional anti business. I wish there was a way to check their IRS filings to see if they carry this as a loss on the books. Destroying your inventory no matter the reason is not a loss. Some pro 2nd Amendment stock holders should demand to know why they are deliberately losing money by destroying inventory and also check the financial statements for how they classify the losses. If they take it as a loss that would be fraud in my book.
It would actually be tax evasion, which is a felony (if the fake write-off is large enough). The IRS limits deductions to expenses that are both "reasonable" and "necessary" to your trade or business. Intentionally destroying inventory does not fall in this category, IMHO. Technically it wouldn't even be inventory since "inventory" is defined as something that you intend to sell. But the point is that the cost of this little show is not deductible. IANAL, but I am a CPA.

In addition, I would expect a shareholder lawsuit if these shenanigans have a significant negative impact on the stock. As the CEO / Board of a publicly traded company you have a fiduciary obligation to protect the financial interests of your investors since you are messing with their company. And I fully expect to see Dick's stock underperform their rivals. Not only will folks stop buying the guns they are still OK with selling, but a lot of us also camp, fish, play golf, have kids in sports, etc., etc. They will lose that business as well.
by Soccerdad1995
Wed Apr 18, 2018 12:36 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Dick's Sporting Goods to destroy all unsold firearms after Parkland shooting
Replies: 34
Views: 10523

Re: Dick's Sporting Goods to destroy all unsold firearms after Parkland shooting

cmgee67 wrote:Dick’s has never really been a good store to begin with. They are like Bass pro with their prices which are always over inflated. I haven’t shopped there in a long time. The last two items I bought from them were some 5.11 pants that were on close out that they were phasing out to carry their own brand. I paid 23$ on one pair then 19$ on the next. That’s the only “deal” I’ve ever gotten from them. I have never purchased a firearm from that store due to the fact that their prices were always too much. Personally I buy my guns from my LGS or academy or online. I honestly don’t see how a lot of retailers are still open when online shopping is they way to go now. Oh and btw how can they say they support the second amendment but destroy firearms? That’s like saying I support driving cars but they could hurt someone so let’s destroy all cars. And that’s the problem. People think guns, cars, knives, blenders, whatever hurt people. Technically they do but they have to be used/controlled by a human. Therefore it’s the person operating the inanimate object and they are evil. NOT THE TOOL.
It's like saying that rings kill people because a person is beaten to death by a man wearing a ring. Ban all rings and you end violence!

Return to “Dick's Sporting Goods to destroy all unsold firearms after Parkland shooting”