TexasCHLforum.com

I meant to say the Alien was already assembled. My OFH was a DIY kit.

I think I would go for the Alien Gear. I've had an Old Faithful for about 2 months and like it a lot. It cost $40. I wanted another for a small, Keltec P32 and heard about Alien Gear. I received it today (2 weeks after I ordered it). I'm so impressed that I wish I could return the OFH. The Alien was $10 less than the OFH and was already assembled. OFH has a huge up charge to simply screw the holster together for you ($40 vs $75 I think). The design is identical. Alien uses thicker leather and at least the same, or thicker, kydex (sp?). Alien has the same warranty and for as long as you own the holster, will also trade out the kydex if you want to carry a different weapon. All the hardware (both Alien and OFH give you a bunch of extras) and clips look identical. I also read on another forum that a guy who purchased an Alien got a thank you letter from Thomas Tedder, the founder of OFH. Hmmmm..... I joined this forum just to answer your question, so I hope it helps.