Allowing people to post comments that mock and belittle a legitimate question. Great Policy. That will really encourage people to participate.tbrown wrote:As someone without a dog in the fight, let me ask, are you familiar with forum rule number two?
Search found 10 matches
Return to “Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in gym?”
- Mon Sep 03, 2012 5:32 pm
- Forum: General Texas CHL Discussion
- Topic: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in gym?
- Replies: 36
- Views: 4801
Re: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in
- Mon Sep 03, 2012 5:24 pm
- Forum: General Texas CHL Discussion
- Topic: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in gym?
- Replies: 36
- Views: 4801
Re: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in
Moderators......did you remove my posts? If so, why do you allow the responses that do nothing but mock and belittle the original question and delete my rebuke to them? Just curious. And do you think allowing those who belittle and mock good questions is productive here and encourages others to ask questions?
- Mon Sep 03, 2012 8:55 am
- Forum: General Texas CHL Discussion
- Topic: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in gym?
- Replies: 36
- Views: 4801
Re: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in
Thanks SlowDave. Your thoughts were my initial thoughts. And as I read in other forums, I see similar opinions. Accidental and or inadvertent exposure is not "intentional".SlowDave wrote:Good discussion. I think I disagree with one aspect though. If the OP removes the firearm under a towel or whatever and does his best to hide it and place in the locker, hiding all the way, and someone somehow gets a little glimpse under the corner of a towel or whatever, to me, that is unintentional and is the same as the guy with the coat that rode up. He was trying to conceal it, just was unsuccessful. Conceal doesn't necessarily mean ON your body, right? Hence purse carry, etc. So, he was moving it from one concealed position to another concealed position under concealment, or at least attempted concealment.
Note: all the other issues are still there, such as taking the ride anyway, lawyer fees, someone seeing you transfer it and then breaking into your locker, etc. Just saying a failed transfer under cover would to me seem to be an unintentional lack of concealment. Thoughts?
I think the bigger issues now are the other ones. Such as the Gym not allowing firearms and my membership getting revoked (if someone should catch a glimpse( and theft, etc.
Thanks for your constructive input. I appreciate it.
- Thu Aug 30, 2012 1:10 pm
- Forum: General Texas CHL Discussion
- Topic: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in gym?
- Replies: 36
- Views: 4801
Re: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in
Good point. Gym parking lots are notorious for car break ins.Slowplay wrote:I know several people that have had wallets & other items stolen from locked lockers while at 24 hour fitness and Lifetime. An alarm on your car/truck and a bolted down console vault is also a good idea as vehicles get hit in gym parking lots too.Oldgringo wrote:Leave it in the car?
- Thu Aug 30, 2012 12:20 pm
- Forum: General Texas CHL Discussion
- Topic: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in gym?
- Replies: 36
- Views: 4801
Re: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in
Wow......good info. I'm thinking now I better just leave it in the car.fickman wrote:A few things from my perspective:
1. Firearms are against the 24 Hour Fitness member contract. It's in the fine print, but it's not enforceable 30.06 language. If discovered, you won't be guilty of criminal trespass, but they can cancel your membership without compensation. I prepaid for mind, so that's a lot to lose. Concealed is concealed.
2. I keep a j-frame in my bag and normally I workout when it's slow enough that I can keep my bag with me.
3. The SuperSport where I go has a few private locker rooms with lockers, a toilet, and a shower inside. If you really need accommodation (and your gym has them), consider using those.
4. I agree with others regarding intentionally failing to conceal. A public restroom / locker room is still public. You have an expectation of privacy in the toilet stalls, but not in the locker room. (You have an expectation of privacy in the locker room to not be video recorded, but that's about it.)
5. I also looked at their video screens to know the security camera coverage for the parking lot. You might be surprised at which spots are covered and which ones aren't - the camera locations can be misleading. I always park squarely in the picture and you can see every approach angle of my vehicle. This tip was to help you, but if you go the same club I do, don't take my spot!
After reading the responses, I think CHL instructors should maybe stress a little more how crucial it is to keep that gun so it's virtually impossible for anyone to see. I mean "unintentional" seems useless. It seems accidental to inadvertent exposure to everything in between is going to be viewed as "intentional" and that needs to be hammered home in the classes.
Thanks........
- Thu Aug 30, 2012 12:13 pm
- Forum: General Texas CHL Discussion
- Topic: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in gym?
- Replies: 36
- Views: 4801
Re: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in
Thanks kjolly, I have worried about that too.....somebody seeing it and stealing it.kjolly wrote:Something that has not been mentioned yet, is if someone sees you stashing the gun they might be tempted to break intot he locker and steal it.
Other scenio is we have a lot of scared liberals that look at guns with fear, trembling and a dime for 911.
Last Christmas overheard conversation of two co-workers on other side of office. One was complaining that his son wanted a toy gun for christmas and he cannot understand how his son got the idea as they do not let him watch any TV shows with guns. At the time I was using a homemade screensaver of guns and I went back to my office and changed screensavers so as not to offend anyone. seemed to me like this man needed a good course in handling guns and needs to take his son to the range to properly educate him. So many fathers in todays liberal society fail to teach their sons safe gun handling and shooting ettiqute.
Say, I notice you have a SCCY CPX Gen 2. Can I ask if you are happy with it? Thanks again.
- Wed Aug 29, 2012 9:48 pm
- Forum: General Texas CHL Discussion
- Topic: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in gym?
- Replies: 36
- Views: 4801
Re: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in
Ok, glad I asked. I see I need to play it safe and virtually eliminate the chance of it being exposed. Thanks all....appreciate it.Keith B wrote:A coat shifting while seated is not intentional. You are intentionally transferring your gun from one location to another. If you can do so and totally conceal it, then you are fine. However, you will be in a gray area if you do not make a good enough effort to conceal it and someone does see it. Best bet is to do as others have said, step into a stall, transfer it to an enclosed pack, then transfer the pack to the locker. Reverse the process when putting the gun back on.NorthDallas7 wrote:I appreciate your response and concern and I will certainly change how I deal with this.C-dub wrote:The person with the coat was unintentional. Your action, while not malicious, is intentional. If someone sees you they could call the police and you could be arrested and it would be legitimate. Unless you change your tactic, you run this risk. Be careful.
But how is my act any different from the guy with the coat? I fully INTENDED to conceal as he did, and the handgun was exposed UNINTENTIONALLY, like his was. In fact, one could argue mine is less serious because the time to place it in the locker is literally seconds compared to minutes , perhaps several minutes , of unintentional exposure with the guy with the coat.
I don't mean to say you are wrong, I just would like if you could explain how mine is INTENTIONAL and his wasn't.
Here is what another person says on another forum on this subject:
"An accidental or inadvertent exposure is not unlawful. Relax"
Again, not saying you are wrong, just looking for clarification. Thanks.
- Wed Aug 29, 2012 9:20 pm
- Forum: General Texas CHL Discussion
- Topic: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in gym?
- Replies: 36
- Views: 4801
Re: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in
I appreciate your response and concern and I will certainly change how I deal with this.C-dub wrote:The person with the coat was unintentional. Your action, while not malicious, is intentional. If someone sees you they could call the police and you could be arrested and it would be legitimate. Unless you change your tactic, you run this risk. Be careful.
But how is my act any different from the guy with the coat? I fully INTENDED to conceal as he did, and the handgun was exposed UNINTENTIONALLY, like his was. In fact, one could argue mine is less serious because the time to place it in the locker is literally seconds compared to minutes , perhaps several minutes , of unintentional exposure with the guy with the coat.
I don't mean to say you are wrong, I just would like if you could explain how mine is INTENTIONAL and his wasn't.
Here is what another person says on another forum on this subject:
"An accidental or inadvertent exposure is not unlawful. Relax"
Again, not saying you are wrong, just looking for clarification. Thanks.
- Wed Aug 29, 2012 9:03 pm
- Forum: General Texas CHL Discussion
- Topic: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in gym?
- Replies: 36
- Views: 4801
Re: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in
Appreciate the responses.
Let me follow up if I can.
Currently, I do make every effort to conceal it while placing it in the locker. I NEVER intend NOT to conceal it. I usually try to slip it into the locker along with other items, trying to cover it. It is in a holster too.
So that being said....what if someone happens to catch a glimpse of it? My instructor told us a story about a guy who's coat had shifted in a restaurant and his gun was exposed long enough for someone to call the police. When the police came, they did not arrest him because it was NOT INTENTIONAL.
I don't want to have to go to a stall or anything like that. I am doing my best to hide it and it sounds like I will have to continue to do that. So now I guess my question is.....doing my best to hide it.....what if someone still manages to catch a glimpse? Obviously, that is not intentional.
Appreciate your responses.
Let me follow up if I can.
Currently, I do make every effort to conceal it while placing it in the locker. I NEVER intend NOT to conceal it. I usually try to slip it into the locker along with other items, trying to cover it. It is in a holster too.
So that being said....what if someone happens to catch a glimpse of it? My instructor told us a story about a guy who's coat had shifted in a restaurant and his gun was exposed long enough for someone to call the police. When the police came, they did not arrest him because it was NOT INTENTIONAL.
I don't want to have to go to a stall or anything like that. I am doing my best to hide it and it sounds like I will have to continue to do that. So now I guess my question is.....doing my best to hide it.....what if someone still manages to catch a glimpse? Obviously, that is not intentional.
Appreciate your responses.
- Wed Aug 29, 2012 8:44 pm
- Forum: General Texas CHL Discussion
- Topic: Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in gym?
- Replies: 36
- Views: 4801
Do I have to hide my handgun while changing/dressing in gym?
I work out every day at 24 hour fitness and I prefer to carry most of the time. So my question is, when I undress and dress in the locker room, can I openly expose the handgun as I remove it from my waist and place it in the locker? I am a little self conscious about it right now and there always seems to be someone nearby who will see it if he happens to look at the right time.
But I hate having to do go through the trouble of hiding it too. It's a hassle. I'd like to be able to simply remove it and place it in the locker without worrying about if anyone sees it or not and breaking the law.
Any guidance on this from a legal perspective?
Thank You.
But I hate having to do go through the trouble of hiding it too. It's a hassle. I'd like to be able to simply remove it and place it in the locker without worrying about if anyone sees it or not and breaking the law.
Any guidance on this from a legal perspective?
Thank You.